There's tons of free info online, plenty of books that are available at the library. Flour, water, and salt are all extremely inexpensive. Even a 5 lb bag of excellent flour like King Arthur Unbleached is just a few bucks.
|King Arthur Flour 100% Organic Unbleached Bread Flour, 5 Pound||156 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
This is a great sourdough starter video tutorial:
Table of Contents
Some of this equipment requires an investment, but you will use that stuff your whole life. Bread is going to be almost free for you after some time.
If cooking is an art, baking is a science. You'll want to be as precise as possible. Have a scale, weigh everything precisely, calibrate your oven, mix things consistently, take note of humidity.
If you want more consistency, you can consider getting:
A Dutch oven is probably the most important accessory you can buy if you're serious about baking bread. You can't really make a good loaf without trapping the moisture in some way. It's an investment.
Get a food scale for more consistent measurements. Once you really learn to bake bread, you won't need a food scale. I'm doing everything by heart now and experimenting more.
Get a proofing basket for fancy looking bread. A proofing basket is a good investment if you're serious about this. It's cheap too. It can also be called a banneton. Proofing baskets should be made out of wood and come with a liner or without one.
Buy cooling racks, but most people have these already. Get a proper cooling rack if you're planning to really get into this hobby. It really helps when you're baking a lot of loaves.
Get a dough scraper. It's useful too. It allows for the handling of high-hydration dough without making your hands messy. It works well for scraping the leftover dough from your work surface and for cutting your dough. A large plastic dough/bowl scraper really upped my game and saved so much time and frustration from the dough sticking to the counter.
And then there different types of flour. Rye is best for starters cause it's the most biologically active. Soft white is suitable for delicate things like pastries, tortillas, and stuff, and it will also lighten/fluff up your loaves of bread if it's partially mixed in. Buckwheat has a hearty/earthy flavor if you want a little of that.
For me I take it one step further and buy grains and grind my grains into flour using an electric mill. I fancy hard red wheat the most. It's expensive but has an incredibly deep taste.
I definitely recommend this book!! Super helpful because it goes into detail about the science of breadmaking, and the role each ingredient plays, rather than just giving you recipes to blindly follow.
Forkish's pizza dough recipes are also amazing. I never thought I could make restaurant-quality pizza at home, but his Overnight Straight Pizza Dough really turns out THAT well for me every time.
If you're serious about making pizza, Ken Forkish also published a specific book on this topic, The Elements of Pizza.
|The Elements of Pizza: Unlocking the Secrets to World-Class Pies at Home [A Cookbook]||381 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|1||Silicone Baking Mat for Pastry Rolling with Measurements, Liner Heat Resistance Table Placemat Pad...||535 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|2||Instant Pot 5252185 Official Mini Loaf Pans, Set of 2, Compatible with 6-quart and 8-quart cookers,...||316 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|3||Non-slip Silicone Pastry Mat Extra Large with Measurements 28''By 20'' for Silicone Baking Mat,...||1,377 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|4||The Ultimate Pizza Making Kit - Our Ultimate 16 inch Round Pizza Stone and 14 inch Pizza Peel...||502 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|5||9 Inch Bread Banneton Proofing Basket - Baking Bowl Dough Gifts for Bakers Proving Baskets for...||1,446 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|6||Bread Bakers Lame Slashing Tool - Dough Making Slasher Tools Baking Sourdough Bread Starter Jar...||178 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|7||Fat Daddio's BP-SET Anodized Aluminum Bread Pan, 7.75 x 3.75 x 2.75 Inch, Set of 2, Silver||686 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|8||Amagabeli Nonstick Perforated Baguette Pan 15" x 13" for French Bread Baking 4 Wave Loaves Loaf Bake...||597 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|9||Bread Baking Kit Gift Set | 9" Banneton Bread Proofing Basket | 2 Baguette Baking Pan | Bread Lame |...||33 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|10||Unicook Heavy Duty Ceramic Pizza Grilling Stone, Baking Stone, Pizza Pan, Perfect for Oven, BBQ and...||456 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|1||Flour Water Salt Yeast: The Fundamentals of Artisan Bread and Pizza [A Cookbook]||1,366 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|2||Bread Baking for Beginners: The Essential Guide to Baking Kneaded Breads, No-Knead Breads, and...||779 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|3||The Bread Baker's Apprentice, 15th Anniversary Edition: Mastering the Art of Extraordinary Bread [A...||176 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|4||Bread Illustrated: A Step-By-Step Guide to Achieving Bakery-Quality Results At Home||402 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|5||Tartine Bread (Artisan Bread Cookbook, Best Bread Recipes, Sourdough Book)||704 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|6||Artisan Bread Cookbook 2020: 20 Amazingly Easy-to-Follow and Foolproof Recipes for Delicious...||14 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|7||The Bread Bible||428 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|8||Paul Hollywood's Bread||203 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|9||Poilâne: The Secrets of the World-Famous Bread Bakery||90 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|10||Living Bread: Tradition and Innovation in Artisan Bread Making||41 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
What is the added benefit of using the Dutch oven? Wouldn't it turn out the same if it was baked without it?
Baking bread uncovered allows the moisture to escape. Baguettes and loaves of bread with a crunchier exterior are often sprayed or misted with water during baking to achieve a crunchy exterior. Bread like sandwich bread, challah, and softer types are baked uncovered, no mist or added steam yielding softer bread with a shiny exterior by use of egg wash before baking.
This is the best Dutch oven on the market, bar none:
A Dutch oven will still retain moisture initially, and you'll probably be able to get the loaf out more quickly. I have made beautiful loaves in an even larger cast iron pot with no problems.
If you have a plain cast-iron pot, don't forget to use parchment paper. I have heard some horror stories of loaves stuck in pots using this method!
The Dutch in the 17th century had a better method for producing cast iron cookware. Something about their process made very smooth cooking surfaces. An Englishman took the method back to England, where they were made and exported heavily to the colonies.
In the Americas, many changes were made to the pots for use during exploration and living in the wild. Dutch ovens became a part of American history as the defacto cookware for those heading west.
A lidded Pullman is a great alternative to a Dutch Oven. Personally, I like a loaf of crusty sandwich bread, so I leave the lid off, but if you want softer crust, the lidded Pullman seems to the best.
I also like brushing the loaf with milk when it comes out.
I usually bake around 450-475 with a Dutch oven.
I usually let it go for 30 minutes with the lid on, and then I remove the lid and let it bake for another 15-20 minutes. Pretty much until I see the ears get as charred as I want.
|1||Lodge 6 Quart Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven. Classic Red Enamel Dutch Oven (Island Spice Red)||8,284 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|2||AmazonBasics Enameled Cast Iron Covered Dutch Oven, 6-Quart, Blue||3,048 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|3||Lodge 5 Quart Cast Iron Dutch Oven. Pre-Seasoned Pot with Lid and Dual Loop Handle||4,587 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|4||Lodge 7.5 Quart Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven. XL Red Enamel Dutch Oven (Island Spice Red) - EC7D43||8,265 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|5||Crock Pot Artisan 7 Quart Enameled Cast Iron Round Dutch Oven, Sapphire Blue - 69145.02||333 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
Cast iron is good, but the reason behind it is to trap the steam and make a nice crust. The same results could be achieved with a clay 'le cloche' type of thing or on the cheap via pizza stone and a lid of some sort.
I've used just about every method out there and can achieve the best results with my le cloche, but this one came out from the stone/lid combo.
I just use a big aluminum lid I got from Sam's club. Put it in the oven while preheating, use gloves to load the bread/lift the lid, and cover for 20 minutes. Voila!
|1||Lodge L10SK3ASHH41B Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet with Red Silicone Hot Handle Holder, 12-Inch||4,885 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|2||Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12.5 inch)||2,829 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|3||Lodge L9OG3 Cast Iron Round Griddle, Pre-Seasoned, 10.5 Inch (Pack of 1)||5,653 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
The pizza stone works well, never had any issues. It's made for that kind of dough as pizza dough is high hydration as well.
|1||Unicook Heavy Duty Ceramic Pizza Grilling Stone, Baking Stone, Pizza Pan, Perfect for Oven, BBQ and...||456 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|2||PentaBeauty Pizza Stone, 16''x 16'' Round Engineered Tuff Cordierite Durable Baking Stones for Ovens...||99 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|3||Pizza Stone, Engineered Tuff Cordierite Durable, Heavy Duty Ceramic, Baking Stone, Pizza Pan,...||105 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
A baking steel offers superior thermal mass, and the results are a bit better with it versus the results with a regular stone once you cover them up. The baking steel is awesome in that it's huge so I can bake larger loaves, but since they're both covered with a lid, they cook more or less on par with one another.
|1||Baking Steel - The Original Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone (14"x16"x1/4")||269 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|2||Pizzacraft PC0313 Rectangular Steel Baking Plate for Oven or BBQ Grill, 22” x 14”||277 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|3||Baking Steel Griddle, 14 " x 18 " x .38 "||45 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
I love making bread in my bread machine. The bread machine takes all the work out, you just put the ingredients in, and 3-6 hours later you have amazing bread.
Bread from the machine will be better than the one from a supermarket but way worse than an artisanal hand-made one.
I almost always make my own hamburger buns. I use a bread machine set to the dough cycle and then form it into buns and bake them. It only takes a couple of hours of wait and only about 15 minutes of active work, and they taste amazing. I just can't eat store-bought buns anymore. They're either disgusting or expensive.
|1||KBS Pro Stainless Steel Bread Machine, 2LB 17-in-1 Programmable XL Bread Maker with Fruit Nut...||1,227 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|2||Oster Bread Maker | Expressbake, 2-Pound Loaf||4,179 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|3||Cuisinart CBK-110P1 Bread Maker, Up To 2lb Loaf, New Compact Automatic||387 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|4||Hamilton Beach 2 lb Digital Bread Maker, Programmable, 12 Settings + Gluten Free, Dishwasher Safe...||2,278 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
|5||Sunbeam Programmable Bread Maker, White||2,407 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
Goodwill and some antique stores will sometimes have Dutch ovens for cheap. They'll be old and probably have roosters or flowers all over them, but as long as it's not rusty, it should be fine.
Typically salt is the key to bread flavor. Using a "pinch" is not enough. I work on a 2% basis (yeast varies depending on your time).
So for a "regular white" 70% hydration recipe, it would be:
10g of salt is not a small amount, its between a teaspoon and a tablespoon in volume.
The recipe makes two loaves.
Regular bread is much easier to work with than sourdough but has a less rich taste.
I make this bread all the time, and the family LOVES it, so I've dug out my recipe, which I got from a youtube video. It's come out well every time. I make the dough in a bread machine but bake in an oven. I also go by weight, so you'll need a scale. The thing about a scale when baking is that if you eventually want to tweak something you can because everything else you've done has been consistent. That and you'll get pretty similar results every time.
The recipe calls for bread flour, but I've also done this with AP flour, and it's come out fine.
For the starter mix:
Heat in a pan until goo. It can be pretty moist. I aim for a Cream of Wheat consistency.
Let goo get back to room temperature before using, though I've dumped it in slightly warm with good results.
The dough should be smooth and only slightly sticky. Proof, flatten, and rest for 15 minutes. Flatten again and shape or put in the bread pan. Rest 30 minutes. Brush with egg wash if you want a perfectly soft top. I often skip that last step, and the top is still soft.
Bake 355F for 25 minutes. About 20 minutes if you're making sub rolls out of it. 15-20 if you're making buns.
There's a lot of ingredients in this type of bread. If you're absolutely brand new to this, you may have a better time starting with plain white bread. Fewer steps and ingredients will just help to simplify the whole process.
Proofing (or rising) dough is when you first make the dough and then you let it sit for a while, typically about an hour, to let the dough roughly double in size. You're allowing the yeast to do its thing so that the final product will come out light and have all those tiny air holes in it. Without proofing, the bread will come out dense and hard.
When you finish kneading the dough, get out a big bowl or just place it on the counter. Put a little oil on it and cover it with plastic or a damp tea towel. Let it sit for roughly an hour until it's doubled in size (no, you don't have to be exactly precise on the doubling). Then you shape it or put it into whatever container you're going to bake it in. Then you let it rise again for about a half-hour.
That final proof takes a little practice, and you'll get better at it. Underproof that final time is ok, but the bread won't be quite as big as it could be. Overproofed, and it'll come out flat and deflated.
Kneading isn't so much about how long you do it, but getting the dough to be the right consistency and smoothness. Generally speaking, the dough shouldn't be too tacky/sticky, it should look smooth, and if you poke the ball with your finger, the dough should softly bounce back. As you get better at knowing when the dough is through with kneading, you'll begin to learn if it needs a touch more water or a touch more flour. Recipes are great to get you very close to that, but they basically all need a little bit of fudging on the part of the baker to add just a touch more water or flour.
Warmth helps the yeast fungus do its magic faster, but there's no temperature requirement. Actually, my pizza dough I'll proof in the refrigerator overnight.
The dough can technically be overkneaded in the same way that it's technically possible to drown in a few tablespoons of water. Realistically, you can't overknead dough.
We love no-knead bread. This recipe has one of the greatest "finished product to effort" ratios around.
We bake a lot of our bread at home, and we use this method. A trick we learned recently is how to make the crust softer.
If you keep the bread for a few days, you can keep it fresher by wrapping it up in a tea towel. But you'll find the crust is lovely and crispy on the first day but gets notably harder in a few days.
So we now lightly brush the top of the loaf with nut oil, macadamia in our case, right after we put the dough in the preheated cast iron pan.
Just take the hot cast iron pan out of the oven, put the dough in the pan, then lightly brush the top of the dough with some nut oil (helps if there isn't too much flour on top) and cook it like normal.
The bread will still be amazing, but the crust will stay lovely and soft for 3-4 days after baking it!
Another great and precise recipe was originally published in the The New York Times.
The first time I tried baking bread I had a few spices at my disposal. I wanted to be fancy, so I started adding a few dashes of different spices. All the spices were labeled in Spanish, so I didn't really know what each one was. I was looking for cinnamon so I added a spice labeled "Comino." I later realized this was Cumin, which is more common for stews, I believe.
Another problem was I added the spices late, so they weren't mixed properly. So I was eating the bread afterward, and it was ok, then I would bite a pocket of Cumin bread, and it tasted like old soggy socks. It was horrible. It took me a while to figure out what was happening.
Once brought a homemade bread to a potluck with the inlaws. Everyone loved it. They loved it enough that there was a vocal disappointment when I didn't bring one the next time we were invited over.
We had dinner with them almost every week. Every time after that, my mother-in-law would call the day before to remind me to bring bread. It became a bit of a chore.
I make my own bread because I hate super soft supermarket bread, not because it's cheaper. I do find it relaxing, which is cheaper than therapy.
High-quality sourdough bread is VERY expensive where I live, and personally, I prefer eating organic unbleached spelt sourdough, which is hard to find.
I find the active time on sourdough to be way, way less than on yeasted bread.
I spend 10 minutes active time mixing the dough, 8-10 hours passive time raising it, with an optional 2 minute turning/kneading time in there, another 10 minutes shaping, a further 2-4 hours passive proving time, and then the time it takes to bake, most of which is passive time. The sourdough starter involves feeding it about 4 times a week; a cup of flour and 5 minutes each time, max.
Using this approach I can bake bread (even during the workweek) without any real-time imposition. It's extremely easy, cost-effective, and tasty. Probably my collection of thrift-shop baking vessels is the most expensive and time-consuming aspect of it all.
As for cost? My bread is way cheaper than commercial bread of any kind. A loaf costs me about 4 cups of flour, about a heaped teaspoon of salt, and water. The cheapest possible sliced white bread around my neck of the woods is about $1.50, and it is pretty unappetizing. Standard sliced white is about $3.00-$5.00, depending on the brand, and sourdough similar to mine but much smaller loaves, $6-10 each.
Baking bread saves a heck of a lot more per year when you have a family. Four people with a couple of slices of toast each at breakfast, sandwiches for lunch, we easily go through a loaf a day, saving about $4/day or $1300/year.
Then start adding in hamburger buns, dinner rolls, and other one-offs, you're up to at least $1500 per year.
From there, start making non-yeasted baked goods. Cookies, muffins, granola bars. I'd say that if you have teenagers in the house you can save at least $2500/year and everyone is eating food that is both tastier and healthier.
Even if it wouldn't be cheaper, I'd still do it as it's a true hobby of mine. With the energy cost involved in actually baking the bread you bake won't be cheaper... but if you know what you're doing, you're going to be tasting a healthier bread with better ingredients.
Don't bake bread for the money, do it for the taste and experience.
Keep a log!
Yep, I do this, and it's invaluable. I have a spreadsheet that lists every variable and a cell for notes/photos, which is insanely useful.
I also make bread pretty much every weekend and I usually make two loaves, but change one variable between the two of them, to get a much better understanding of how the changes affect the outcome. For example, this past weekend, for the final proof I sent one loaf directly to the fridge to retard and let the other proof at room temp for just over an hour. When I baked them the next day the difference was astounding!
Always remember that sticky dough makes good bread! Try working with very high-hydration dough and very high temperatures in the oven. That's the secret to amazing loaves.
I've baked through 200lb of flour and now I am baking my way through Jeffrey Hamelman's bread Bible.
|Bread: A Baker's Book of Techniques and Recipes||207 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
I tried baking bread on and off for literally decades before it all came together for me. The turning point for me was the gift of a sourdough starter that really worked. That was before Youtube and all this Internet info and I just didn't know how to make proper starter by myself. Once you get a good one, everything else just falls into place. Or at least it did for me.
Hearing crackling of my first loaf of bread is something I will never forget.
Making a perfect sourdough loaf is a 3 day process and if you try to rush any step, you can always tell in the final bake. Take your time. It's a lesson in baking and living life that I'm still working on 🙂
Which bread stays fresh longer?
Fresh bread is definitely better on day one out of the oven. But I will take a 3 day old loaf of bread from the grocery store over a 3 day old home baked loaf of bread.
So if by better, you mean superior taste for a day, then yes. But for some people, better means that it has a longer shelf life so there is less waste.
I have made that exact title loaf from FSWY without salt once. My mother in law was on a low salt diet so I made it as usual just without salt. It was very flat and not tasty. I recommend using a different recipe. There are some types of bread that have little to no salt but the FSWY loaves really rely heavily on salt for flavor. A sourdough works better for people who need to limit salt intake.
If you need to limit your sodium intake, you can replace salt with Morton Lite Salt. It contains half sodium and half potassium and it's better for you, in general.
|Morton Lite Salt, With Half The Sodium Of Table Salt, 11 oz||116 reviews||Check Price and Reviews|
I think depending on the moisture, the point for recognising if it has been kneaded enough changes quite a bit. Like I said, my go to is to let it ferment over night and I don't need to knead it all that much/at all. More specific than "it should be smooth" I couldn't tell you.
How yeasty are we talking? Notice how long you're letting the dough to raise. Because 3h is not that much for the first fermentation (depending on the temperature of the room and how much yeast you put in in regards to flour, and in this case it doesn't seem like too much). You could try another variety of yeast if you don't like that one.
Watch out so the bread is not too dense — and I think that has to do with not letting it have the final proof and/or not developing the gluten enough. Since I'm lazy, what I do is mix ingredients except yeast, let it sit for 30 min and then add yeast and knead it until smooth. Then, cover, put in fridge overnight. Next day, punch the dough down, shape it, let it proof and then it can be baked.
I don't weigh or measure, and have had very few failures. It's more about the look/feel of the dough.
It's practice/repetition, I think. After a while you just get to know what's going to work, from previous experience.
That, and responding to the way the ingredients are. Flour seems to vary a whole lot in how much water it can absorb, so if it looks dry, I add more water. Also sourdough starter changes with the seasons and so you have no choice other than to be more flexible with it, and let it rise until it's 'done' (or conversely stoke up the oven a bit ahead of schedule).
So just keep baking, and one day you'll find yourself thinking, 'hmm, this needs more X or Y' and you'll be on your way.
Learn the art of bread baking:
This guy is baking his breads in lava in Iceland.
I wonder if it actually tastes better compared to an oven-baked bread...
You don't really need all these accessories to make amazing bread, but they make your life easier. If I could choose only only 1 item to make my baking awesome, I'd choose really good flour.
King Arthur flour is very good, but it money is no object and I want to bake some exceptional loaves, I always buy flour from Great River Organic Milling. It costs way more than regular flour, but I'm glad to pay premium for its quality.